An appeal brought by U.S. service members seeking damages for radiation exposure from the March 2011 nuclear disaster at the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant in Japan ended up rejected in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
The lawsuit, filed in federal district court in California, said Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO) and General Electric (GE) were liable for radiation to which the service members said they were exposed to while assisting with the humanitarian relief effort in the region. TEPCO owns and operates the Fukushima plant; GE manufactured the plant’s reactors.
The Fukushima disaster occurred in March 2011, when the nuclear facility operated by TEPCO was hit by an earthquake and then a tsunami, which swamped power generators and caused a triple meltdown.
Each of the companies sought dismissal of the claims against it. Citing a Japanese statute called the Act on Compensation for Nuclear Damage (Compensation Act), GE argued only TEPCO could end up liable for the plaintiffs’ alleged injuries. TEPCO, for its part, argued the district court lacked jurisdiction to hear the case and that even if the court had jurisdiction, international comity concerns shielded TEPCO from prosecution. The district court agreed with both companies and granted their respective motions to dismiss.
In its review of the district court’s ruling, the Ninth Circuit conducted a three-part choice-of-law analysis to determine whether the Japanese Compensation Act should be applicable in the case.
First, the court observed that the Compensation Act would limit liability exclusively to TEPCO, whereas the laws of California would allow the plaintiffs to pursue claims against GE. Moving on to the next step in the analysis, the court found Japan and California had a legitimate interest in the application of their respective laws. The court concluded in the third part of its analysis that Japan’s interest in protecting the Japanese nuclear industry outweighed California’s interest in ensuring compensation for injured California residents.
In light of this conclusion, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision to dismiss the claims against GE.
Finally, the Ninth Circuit held the district court did not abuse its discretion when it ruled international comity concerns compelled dismissal of the remaining claims against TEPCO.
Although consideration of the international comity doctrine involves several factors, the court noted in particular the Japanese government had voiced strong opposition to continuation of the proceedings in the United States, while the U.S. government had expressed no comparable objection to adjudication of the claims in Japan.

