By Gregory Hale
Never in our history have our workplaces been so safe and our workers so well protected, but at the same time, we are seeing a slow increase in serious accidents.

“Some of the safest organizations in the world were safe until the last move, and then a catastrophic event occurs,” said Corrie Pitzer, founder and chief executive of Vancouver, British Columbia-based SAFEmap during his GCPS keynote Monday at the virtual Spring 21 + 17th GCPS joint AIChE and CCPS meeting. “I have studied the 6,516 people that died in 27 incidents. It doesn’t make sense. Something is wrong. If you look at what is currently happening in the United States is, we are killing more people in the last 10 years than what did before. The fatality rate is not improving. We are supposed to be at the safest point in our history. What is going on? Organizations are using the same techniques and systems in safety that we have been using for decades. Some of these things are 60 to 70 years old and we are still using them. Is that what is turning against us. The safety industry has gotten stuck.”

Pitzer then talked about the seven ideas considered good safety ideas that fail.

Swiss Cheese Model
The first idea is the swiss cheese model, he said.

Schneider Bold

“We find the holes in the catastrophic events and say these are the problems and you can’t argue with that, but what you can’t see are the emerging holes. This has kept us in the reactive model, instead of in a proactive mode. It has seduced us into thinking safety is simple,” he said.

The failed idea is people cause accidents.

“We have been living with this for decades,” Pitzer said. “We have had a whole era for the past few decades called behavioral safety, based on the principal that humans are fallible. Of course, humans are fallible. Most of the time we come up with reasons like people are complacent, negligent and they made poor choices. What we don’t seem to grasp is most accidents happened a long time ago, way upstream. An incident is just the symptom of what has happened way upstream.”

The third dangerous idea in safety, he said, is the standard operating procedure.

What happened in Piper Alpha disaster is a well-known example. The reason 167 workers died in the accommodation block was because they followed the evacuation procedure that told them to head there in case of an emergency. The problem was the fire started right underneath the accommodation block, he said. The 26 people that survived jumped into the water or were blown into the sea.

“I am not saying we should break rules,” Pitzer said. “I am saying inside the rules, we are falling victim to the cult of compliance. When people are operating in a cult, they drink the Kool-Aid and that is the foundational problem following the standard operating procedure.”

The fourth most dangerous idea is the hierarchy of control, he said.

Less Risk, More Risky
There is great value in controls. “When we see more risk, we take more care,” Pitzer said. “When we see less risk, we act more risky. What is the sole purpose of the safety function? It is to create a safer workplace and engineer a safer environment. When people see less risk in those environments, what do they do? They start to act in more risky ways.”

The fifth more dangerous idea is the risk matrix.

“The risk matrix is fundamentally unable to deal with the illusion that we have pinpointed risk, quantified it, and put it in a block where we can now deal with it from this point on. Risk is dynamic and it constantly shifts in an organization in a complex way.”

The sixth most dangerous idea is the metrics in safety, he said.

“We believe very strongly in the old axiom is what gets measured, gets done,” Pitzer said. “In safety, if you measure metrics, you measure accidents and there can be only one logical target and that is zero. If that is the case, we would have the misplaced confidence that zero was safe.”

The seventh more dangerous idea is the idea of excellence in safety.

The Deepwater Horizon incident is a perfect example, he said, where BP had a ceremony the day of the incident celebrating the fact they did not have a safety incident in seven years.

“Who would for one moment believe they worked on a platform for seven years without an incident? Pitzer asked. “They clearly lied about it. They pretended to be safe. Surely the management of BP must have known it was not possible.”

Safety Excellence
When it comes to safety excellence, as we approach the next target level, “we increase the fear to fail. The closer we get, the bigger the fear gets.”

With the ideas of safety considered ancient, Pitzer talked about the R4 design for safety.

“Safety is the readiness to respond to risks relentlessly,” he said. “If you define your safety, you will change everything where you are creating a culture that is relentlessly focusing on safety on all levels, from strategic to technical and operational. In the same way accidents are created upstream, incredible competence is also created upstream in the organization in the processes, the systems and in the culture. It is not what happens in the front end, it is what happens deep inside your company in the complex iterations of everything that comes together.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This