Joe Sullivan is facing charges of obstructing justice and concealing a felony for the alleged cover-up, prosecutors said. Sullivan “engaged in a scheme to withhold and conceal” the breach from regulators and failed to report it to law enforcement or the public, according to a complaint filed in federal court in California on Thursday.
“Silicon Valley is not the Wild West,” said David Anderson, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of California. “We expect good corporate citizenship. We expect prompt reporting of criminal conduct. We expect cooperation with our investigations. We will not tolerate corporate cover-ups. We will not tolerate illegal hush money payments.”
“Concealing information about a felony from law enforcement is a crime,” said Deputy Special Agent in Charge Craig Fair. “While this case is an extreme example of a prolonged attempt to subvert law enforcement, we hope companies stand up and take notice. Do not make the problem worse for your customers, and do not cover up criminal attempts to steal people’s personal data.”
Pivotal Role
The complaint describes how Sullivan played a pivotal role in responding to FTC inquiries about Uber’s cyber security. Uber had been hacked in September of 2014 and the FTC was gathering information about that 2014 breach. The FTC demanded responses to written questions and required Uber to designate an officer to provide testimony under oath on a variety of topics. Sullivan assisted in the preparation of Uber’s responses to the written questions and was designated to provide sworn testimony on a variety of issues. On November 14, 2016, 10 days after providing his testimony to the FTC, Sullivan received an email from a hacker informing him Uber had been breached again. Sullivan’s team was able to confirm the breach within 24 hours of his receipt of the email.
Rather than report the 2016 breach, Sullivan took deliberate steps to prevent knowledge of the breach from reaching the FTC, officials said. For example, Sullivan sought to pay the hackers off by funneling the payoff through a bug bounty program — a program in which a third party intermediary arranges payment to “white hat” hackers who point out security issues but have not actually compromised data.
Uber paid the hackers $100,000 in BitCoin in December 2016, despite the fact the hackers refused to provide their true names. In addition, Sullivan sought to have the hackers sign non-disclosure agreements, officials said. The agreements contained a false representation the hackers did not take or store any data. When an Uber employee asked Sullivan about this false promise, Sullivan insisted the language stay in the non-disclosure agreements. Moreover, after Uber personnel were able to identify two of the individuals responsible for the breach, Sullivan arranged for the hackers to sign fresh copies of the non-disclosure agreements in their true names. The new agreements retained the false condition that no data had been obtained. Uber’s new management ultimately discovered the truth and disclosed the breach publicly, and to the FTC, in November 2017. Since that time, Uber has responded to additional government inquiries.
The criminal complaint said Sullivan deceived Uber’s new management team about the 2016 breach. Specifically, Sullivan failed to provide the new management team with critical details about the breach. In August of 2017, Uber named a new chief executive. In September 2017, Sullivan briefed Uber’s new chief executive about the 2016 incident by email. Sullivan asked his team to prepare a summary of the incident, but after he received their draft summary, he edited it. His edits removed details about the data the hackers had taken and falsely stated that payment had been made only after the hackers had been identified.
Hackers Plead Guilty
The two hackers identified by Uber were prosecuted in the Northern District of California. Both pleaded guilty on October 30, 2019, to computer fraud conspiracy charges and now await sentencing. The criminal complaint makes clear “both [hackers] chose to target and successfully hack other technology companies and their users’ data” after Sullivan failed to bring the Uber data breach to the attention of law enforcement.
Sullivan has served as chief security officer at Internet security company Cloudflare since 2018. Before joining Uber in 2015, he worked at Facebook for six years, including as chief security officer.
Before moving into tech, Sullivan spent two years prosecuting computer hacking and intellectual property crimes as an assistant U.S. Attorney in the Northern District of California — the office that brought the charges against him.
If found guilty, Sullivan faces up to eight years in prison, as well as potential fines of up to $500,000.

