ExxonMobil Oil Corp. must provide information to the U.S. Chemical Safety Board (CSB) relating to a tank filled with hydrofluoric acid that narrowly escaped damage during a 2015 refinery explosion in Torrance, CA, a federal appeals court panel ruled Monday.
An explosion in the refinery’s fluid catalytic cracking unit Feb. 18, 2015, shook the surrounding area with the force of a 1.7-magnitude earthquake and propelled a 40-ton piece of debris about 100 feet, where it landed within five feet of a tank containing thousands of gallons of modified hydrofluoric acid, according to the CSB.
Hydrofluoric acid is a highly corrosive liquid that dissolves glass. Breathing it can cause lung damage and skin contact can cause severe burns and death. In a part of its investigation, the CSB issued subpoenas for information regarding the contents of the tank, citing hazards and related safety concerns.
According to the CSB, ExxonMobil refused to provide this information, and a lower court had ruled the information was not sufficiently relevant to the agency’s investigation.
In the ruling Monday, a three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with the board’s position the subpoenas related to the modified hydrofluoric acid tank were relevant and within the board’s authority because the risks of an accidental release of modified hydrofluoric acid were among the facts, conditions, and circumstances of the February 15, 2015, explosion: “The Board is not limited to the facts, conditions, and circumstances that caused the accidental release. The Board should look as well to the effects and the potential harm, were a similar incident to occur. The presence of two tanks full of toxic chemicals on the site of the explosion, very close to where debris from that explosion landed, is among the circumstances of the explosion.”
In its appeal, the CSB challenged portions of five of the denied requests. The requests at issue all related to the alkylation unit and the modified hydrofluoric acid stored there.
The disputed portions of the requests are as follows:
1. All risk assessments performed for the alkylation unit for the past 15 years.
2. Provide information related to the vendors and manufacturers of the modified hydrofluoric acid used in the alkylation unit including a list of vendors, manufacturers, and quantity purchased annually, dates and contact information.
3. All studies, reports, analysis, data, experiments, modeling, technical analysis and specifications related to the same or similar modified hydrofluoric acid used in the alkylation unit at the time of the February 18 incident including but not limited to: records provided or shown to the city of Torrance or their representatives, ExxonMobil or third party records, records provided by the manufacturer or vendor, records relating to the documented or asserted degree of [hydrofluoric acid] vapor suppression for modified [hydrofluoric acid], and industry and/or Mobil/ExxonMobil studies, experiments, modeling of modified [hydrofluoric acid] and its effectiveness in suppressing vapor compared to unmodified [hydrofluoric acid].
4. All records related to the volume and concentration of hydrofluoric acid contained in the each of the two alkylation unit [hydrofluoric] acid settlers at the time of the February 18 incident.
5. All documentation identifying Alkylation Unit siting hazards, risks, and safety concerns. Documentation includes calculations, recommendations, resolutions, preventative measures implemented, mitigate measures implemented, plot plans, simulations, and toxic, flammable, and explosive hazards identified.
“The CSB is hopeful that Exxon will cooperate in providing information on the HF tanks to the CSB as promptly as possible, just as it has cooperated in the past,” said CSB’s Interim Executive Authority Dr. Kristen Kulinowski. “With this information, the CSB will be able to complete a critical part of its investigation into the Torrance refinery explosion that has been stalled due to litigation.”
ExxonMobil was not immediately available for comment.

