By Gregory Hale
An Iowa agricultural business, New Cooperative, suffered a ransomware attack and the criminal gang is demanding a $5.9 million ransom. And while the victim and the attacker quibble over if the organization is considered critical infrastructure or not, a vital system is shut down.
New Cooperative confirmed it had been hit with a cyberattack either late Friday or early Saturday and shut down its systems in response. Researchers are saying the cyber gang called BlackMatter, which has Russian ties, perpetrated the assault.
While ransomware has been an issue within the industry for quite some time, the number of organizations suffering from an attack seems to growing larger.
In May, Colonial Pipeline suffered an attack which ultimately led to the company shutting down operations and paying a $4.4 million ransom. Another agriculture industry company suffered an attack in May. Meat producer, JBS, suffered an attack by REvil, a gang that researchers said has ties to BlackMatter.
“Out of an abundance of caution, we have proactively taken our systems offline to contain the threat, and we can confirm it has been successfully contained,” New Cooperative said in a statement. “We also quickly notified law enforcement and are working closely with data security experts to investigate and remediate the situation.”
New Cooperative is a grain collective based out of Fort Dodge, Iowa. In negotiations dated Sept. 19 and posted online, a person speaking on behalf of New Cooperative said the attack would cause severe problems in the food supply chain.
“We are critical infrastructure – we [sic] intertwined with the food supply chain in the U.S.,” New Cooperative wrote in a message on Twitter. “If we are not able to recover very shortly, there is going to be a very very public disruption in the grain, pork and chicken supply chain. About 40 percent of grain production runs on our software, and 11 million animal feed schedules rely on us.”
If we’re relying on promises from ransomware orgs about who they will or won’t attack, we’re in a bad position, said Marty Edwards, vice president of OT Security at Tenable.
“We’re yet again in the midst of a massive ransomware attack on critical infrastructure. Whether this attack will result in food shortages due to panic buying or operational downtime, like we saw in the aftermath of Colonial Pipeline, is unknown.
“Despite BlackMatter having previously agreed not to target critical infrastructure, New Cooperative wasn’t spared. While CISA defines critical infrastructure as 16 different sectors, including food and agriculture, are we really surprised that bad actors don’t follow the same guidelines as the U.S. government? If our best defense against widespread, damaging ransomware attacks on critical services is to take the word of cybercriminals, we’re in an even worse position than I thought.”
The negotiator for New Cooperative said the Department of Homeland Security’s Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency would be demanding answers within 12 hours, and called attention to BlackMatter’s claim that it doesn’t target critical infrastructure.
BlackMatter’s negotiator answered, “You do not fall under the rules.”
The federal government has labeled “food and agriculture” one of the nation’s critical infrastructure sectors.
Nick Cappi, cyber vice president for portfolio strategy and enablement at Hexagon, said attacks on critical infrastructure such as this one should be treated like a terrorism situation.
“Quasi-terrorism is still terrorism, and we need to treat it as such,” Cappi said. “Holding an entire organization (and the livelihoods of the employees) hostage shouldn’t be viewed any lesser than any other form of terrorism. No one knows when the next cyber-attack is going to happen or what unknown (or unmitigated) vulnerabilities they are going to exploit. As an industry, we can’t think we are going to drive down risk to an acceptable level by purely looking at reducing the probability of an attack.
“We must start focusing on reducing the consequence of an attack, OT resiliency, specifically Mean Time to Recovery (MTTR). Recent events prove OT resiliency and MTTR is a gap in our security strategy. OT resiliency will give us the ability to recover from events like this timely, and without paying the ransom. If ransomware isn’t a profit center because customers can recover on their own with little business impact, events like this might just go away on their own.”
In essence, to stop these types of attacks, the public and private sectors will have to work together.
“We aren’t dealing with lone wolf ‘hackers’ here. And, by treating them as such, we’re doing a lot more harm than good. These groups run large-scale, organized criminal operations in the digital world. They have help desks, payroll and support centers. Stopping these attacks and the cybercriminals behind them has to be a coordinated effort across the public and private sectors,” Edwards said.

