It is always a debate amongst security professionals about if a victim should pay after being victimized in a ransomware attack.

Usually, the professionals say, the victim should not pay. Law enforcement usually says, don’t pay. But when it comes right down to it, the victim knows the focused details for their security program and they also know time is money, so they have to make the difficult decision of whether the company should pay or not.

In the Colonial Pipeline incident, where the company’s IT network was being held for ransom, the company paid a reported $4.4 million to get operations back up and running to prevent an ever increasing gasoline shortage from getting worse.

Now, one of the largest insurance companies in the United States, CNA Financial, agreed to a $40 million payment to restore access to its systems following a ransomware attack, according to a report with Bloomberg.

The $40 million payment ended up paid out two weeks after ransomware crippled CNA Financial’s networks.

Schneider Bold

People close to the matter said during the cyberattack, employees were locked out of the company’s systems and attackers stole confidential data.

CNA said a “sophisticated cybersecurity attack” was detected on March 21 that caused “network disruption and impacted certain CNA systems.”

In an update on May 12, the insurance giant said third party cyberforensics experts were investigating the incident, in which the ransomware group appears to have conducted all of its activities prior to March 21 and have not accessed the CNA environment since.

Professional ransomware groups often quietly steal information before encryption begins in order to perform a double-extortion attack, where companies that refuse to pay are then faced with the prospect of sensitive data being published online.

The company did not say what information was stolen, but said “we do not believe that the systems of record, claims systems, or underwriting systems, where the majority of policyholder data — including policy terms and coverage limits — is stored, were impacted.”

CNA has since restored its systems and is fully operational.

In a statement, a CNA spokesperson said the insurance firm will not comment on the ransom, adding CNA “followed all laws, regulations, and published guidance” while handling the cyberattack.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This