By Gregory Hale
Lock it up and throw away the key, glue it up and don’t allow anything in, turn off all access and don’t allow anyone to use a USB in this facility. Those are all reactions to a possible attack point in any system: Using a USB, memory stick, flash drive or a thumb drive.
In reality, though, workers use USBs to get valuable data or to download important code to add to software or fix issues. Like it or not, it happens in all plants and the problem is USB-borne malware continues to be a major risk for industrial operators.
Along those lines, 59 percent of total threats in the latest Honeywell Industrial Cybersecurity USB Threat Report 2020 had the ability to impact industrial control and process automation systems, up from 26 percent from an earlier report in 2018. It also appears the industry is seeing a much higher density of significant threats that are more targeted and more dangerous.
“The amount of malware has not really changed that much, but the concentration of severe malware has definitely increased,” said Eric Knapp, chief engineer and director of technology for Honeywell Industrial Cyber Security. “It think it is unlikely the person carrying the USB drive deliberately put the attacks on there, but the concentration of malware indicates the people that are spreading the malware are aware if they get certain types of malware on a device it will get carried into places they want.”
Honeywell’s Cybersecurity GARD Threat team analyzed USB usage and behavioral data, using the GARD Threat Engine. Data for this report ended up limited to threats detected by Honeywell’s USB security platform: Honeywell Secure Media Exchange (SMX). SMX analyzes USB devices used in industrial facilities, providing a highly focused view of critical infrastructure USB activity. Industries in the report include oil and gas, energy, food, chemical, shipping, buildings, aerospace, manufacturing, and pulp and paper among others. Data ended up collected from over 60 countries across North America, South America, Europe, the Middle East, and Asia. This sample set represents only files actively carried into production control facilities via USB removable storage devices, during normal day-to-day operations.
Sophisticated Attacks
In the first USB Threat Report in 2018, 44 percent of the locations studied had detected and blocked at least one malicious or suspicious file. While that increased slightly in the latest report, with 45 percent of locations blocking at least one threat.
The difference, though, is the types of threats detected. Two years ago, it was more malware that appeared as though it was on the USB by accident. Now, however, this is more sophisticated malware targeting USB devices.
“We found more than 50 percent of the malware found was designed for remote access to download additional tools,” Knapp said. APT attackers are using malware designed for USB drives. If an integrator or an employee without knowledge their drive is infected, by carrying it on site, the adversary as accomplished his goal and crossed the air gap. We saw a lot of malware that is trying to open a back door which seems like a deliberate attempt to carry the malware on the USB and carry it around the air gap and then open a remote connection so they can get directly into the industrial environment.”
In 2018, 14 percent of total threats detected ended up developed specifically to target industrial systems, leveraging a specific vulnerability in industrial devices or protocols. In 2020, same types of threats dropped to 11 percent. However – and this is a big however – 59 percent of threats in the 2020 study had the ability to impact industrial control and process automation systems, up from 26 percent.
Why is there such a huge jump? In one word: Ransomware. Ransomware jumped to 17 percent this time compared to 7 percent. Researchers did not consider ransomware “OT specific” unless it specifically targeted an industrial device or protocol, and thus did not contribute to the 11 percent figure. However, the increase in ransomware in OT indicates industrial organizations are the focus of attacks, even if it is not OT-specific. Add in the ransomware component, and the overall threats go up to 28 percent.
While ransomware did increase to 17 percent, the largest threat involved Remote Access Trojans (RATs) and backdoors, at 34 percent (up from 32 percent in 2018) and Droppers, which tied for second at 17 percent (up from 12 percent). In industrial environments, where network access is difficult, gaining a foothold via USB to establish remote access and download new malware makes sense. Establishing a persistent backdoor with command and control makes it possible to create a more coordinated attack.
A Growing Threat
Ransomware continues to be a growing threat. Ransomware campaigns will target specific geographies, demographics, and vertical markets that will most likely pay. The increase in ransomware on removable media in OT environments is a result of specifically targeting industrial manufacturing and critical infrastructure, which ransomware creators see as having great monetary potential. This certainly seems to be the case with Ekans (Snake backward) ransomware that just hit Italian multinational energy company Enel Group and the European and Japanese operations at the auto manufacturer Honda among others, and other ransomware threats found in industrial organizations.
As mentioned in the 2018 report, there was an abundance of “junkware” that indicated poor overall USB hygiene, there was a noticeable reduction in Potentially Unwanted Applications (PUA), non-targeted bots, adware, spyware, and hacktools (22 percent compared to 39 percent in 2018). At the same time, there was an increase in Trojans, worms, rootkits, and viruses (78 percent from 59 percent). Simply put, threat-for-threat, the malware present on USB removable media represents a higher risk than in the past.
The following are key factors in the report operators should be aware of:
- Evidence indicates new threat variants are hitting more quickly, specifically via USB, and specifically targeting industrials. To this end, existing controls should undergo re-examination, and users should re-evaluate patch cycles in an attempt to close the Mean Time to Remediation (MTTR). External controls to provide real-time detection and protection of key systems should also be a consideration, as well as integrated monitoring and incident response procedures.
- USB security must include technical controls and enforcement. Relying on policy updates or people training alone will not suffice for scalable threat prevention.
- Outbound network connectivity from process control networks should undergo tight controls, and those restrictions should end up enforced by network switches, routers and firewalls. While USB drives are useful vectors of initial infection, the attack types here reveal a tendency for hackers to establish remote access, and to download additional payloads as needed.
- Ransomware is an increasingly serious threat to industrial facilities. The financial losses of ransomware can go away by maintaining regular backups and having a tested recovery process in place.
- Security upkeep remains important: Anti-virus software deployed in process control facilities needs constant updates to be effective.
- Patching and hardening of end nodes remain necessary, despite the challenges of patching production systems. While there are sophisticated and targeted attacks, old threats were also out there that could easily end up mitigated by keeping the infrastructure current.
- Legacy USB devices pose a risk. In addition to potential vulnerability to BadUSB or other firmware corruption, older USB devices are susceptible to errors or corruption of the boot sectors and filesystems that can impact the reliability of older operating systems and even introduce new vulnerabilities – putting data and system integrity at risk.
Whether USB usage end up banned from a facility or not, removable media remains a threat, and it is continuing to rise.
“It is our responsibility to assume we are not catching everything, and we strive to improve that,” Knapp said. “People’s security levels have increased, and it is looking better.”


