By Gregory Hale
In the cybersecurity world, it is very easy to get caught up in the dynamic nature of a fast-evolving environment where the latest threat or hack or vulnerability captures the attention of the industry.
That is all well and good for the highly informed security professionals toiling on the front line fighting off the latest attack, but what about those just getting involved and are looking to start up a program or further advance a beginning program to elevate it one more level?
The chemical industry gets it and that is why they created multiple sessions during its 2020 AIChE Spring Meeting & 16th Global Congress on Process Safety last week devoted to understanding cybersecurity and risk management. Risk management is not really anything new as the chemical industry works with it all the time when it comes to process safety.
“Industrial control system cybersecurity is all about risk management,” said John Cusimano during one of his talks on risk management at the conference. “It is understanding and identifying the risk and mitigating the risk to reduce the overall risk exposure. Understanding and ranking risk is a critical first step.”
Cusimano went on to say risk and security risk are sometimes misapplied. Risk, he said, is the exposure to the possibility of loss, injury or adverse or unwelcome circumstance. “Risk is a function of the likelihood and probability of something happening and the consequence of the impact occurring.”
Security risk, however, has a slightly different definition, he said.
“Security risk is the function of the likelihood of a threat source exercising a particular vulnerability and the resulting impact of the adverse effect on the organization. Security risk is a function of threats, vulnerabilities that lead to an impact or consequence.
“At any given time, there are going to be threats impacting a system,” Cusimano said. “At any given time, there are going to be vulnerabilities in a control system. It is really where the two come together where a threat exploits a vulnerability and it results in some negative consequence or impact. The impacts can result in something serious that can result in health, safety, environmental, equipment damage loss production off spec product and regulatory fines and other issues.”
While there are multiple types of assessment techniques out there, but a true risk assessment must consider all three: Threats, vulnerabilities and consequences (or impact), he said.
Risk assessments are not new science.
One way to start a focus on risk assessment is by applying IEC security standard 62443-3-2 which is called “Security Risk Assessment for System Design.” The standard lists requirements for good security risk assessments of control systems. The standard, though, is not prescriptive in nature; it defines what you should do, but not how you should do it, he said.
While a standard is a good place to start, Cusimano said there are methodologies that can help bring the standard to life for a company.
One is the Consequence-driven Cyber-informed Engineering (CCE) process created by the Idaho National Labs. There are four steps in this approach:
1. Consequence prioritization, which determines the crown jewels that need protection
2. System of systems breakdown
3. Consequence-based targeting, which gives a kill chain analysis
4. Mitigations and protections, which gives kill chain mitigations
Another methodology is the Cyber Process Hazard Analysis (PHA), which is a safety-oriented approach that leverages process safety practices and brings them into cybersecurity, Cusimano said. This process shows what cyber consequences could result and then drills down on how that could happen. No one person in a facility will understand threats and consequences, it takes a team approach.
In a CyberPHA, the user can:
- Document the system
- Conduct a vulnerability assessment
- Partition the system
- Conduct a risk assessment
- Create mitigation planning
In a CyberPHA it is possible to create a systematic approach to assessing ICS cyber risk. In the end, it delivers at risk-ranked mitigation plan. Benefits of the CyberPHA are integration with process risk management provides management with consistent ranking of risk, Cusimano said. In addition, it creates a cross-functional team approach that encourages collaboration, practical solution and buy in.
Being able to wrap your arms around understanding risk and figuring out possible consequences, a manufacturer could develop a program or start to elevate it to ensure a more secure environment.

