By Gregory Hale
Using a CyberPHA to understand risks and consequences for a network continues to gain traction throughout the manufacturing automation sector, but in order for it to resonate with non-technical senior management a simpler visualization procedure can help illuminate the process for company leaders.
That is where bow tie analysis comes into play.
“Modern basic process control systems and safety instrumented systems are often networked and those networks are often connected to the plant network and those plant networks are often connected to the business networks and those networks are often connected to the internet,” said John Cusimano, vice president industrial cybersecurity with aeSolutions in a Wednesday session at the virtual 2020 Mary Kay O’Connor Process Safety Symposium. “Control and safety systems particularly when they are connected are subject to cyber compromise that could impact one or more independent layer of protection at the same time.”
A CyberPHA, or cyber process hazards analysis, is a safety-oriented methodology to conduct a security risk assessment for an industrial control system or safety instrumented system (ICS/SIS). It is a systematic, consequence-driven approach that is aligned with ISA/IEC 62443-3-2 and ISA TR84.00.09 standards. It leverages established process safety information and techniques like a PHA, HAZOP and LOPA. It also integrates multiple engineering disciplines and delivers a risk-ranked mitigation plan.
Team Activity
“At its core, a CyberPHA is a team activity just like your traditional process safety PHA, you really need input from multiple subject matter experts, people who know how the system operates, how the systems are used and what the business requirements of that system are so this isn’t a process that you can just go through and complete with one or two people,” said Jacob Morella, industrial cybersecurity technical project team manager at aeSolutions.
“The CyberPHA really takes the methodology from process safety and extends and adapts it for cyber risks,” Morella said. “So, just like the safety PHA process, we’re looking at causes of a deviation. Whereas the safety PHA typically focuses on reliability and hardware failures or human error, a CyberPHA is focusing more on tampering, or issues with the control system itself.”
Traditional PHA covers your hardware failures, or your instrumentation failures, he said. The CyberPHA is looking for worst case consequences and causes that could be affected by cyber scenarios, and then building out the threat sources and threat scenarios. It ends up being focused on the potential causes of a cyber event, and how you prevent each one of those potential causes, Morella added.
The CyberPHA process starts out by documenting the system, then undergoing a vulnerability assessment, then partition the system, risk assessment workshop and then the final part is mitigation planning.
Interpreting Results
When completed CyberPHA results end up presented in a tabular format very similar to how a traditional PHA would present its results. There is a large amount of valuable information contained in these in these tables. In and of itself, the details are all there, but the problem is leadership could have difficulty interpreting this and following the train of thought from consequence through to how recommendations end up tied together.
“If we’re going to ask leadership to make some decisions on funding, we have to have them understand these scenarios,” said Tim Gale, industrial cybersecurity and process safety specialist. “So, we would like for them to be able to have a methodology that’s easier to understand than this tabular format.”
That is where the bow tie analysis comes in.
Bow Tie
“A bow tie is a simple process that graphically depicts pathways from cause to consequence. We use them to help us illustrate high risk events, that’s intended to communicate ranges of cause and the consequences of an event and controls that are in place to prevent the risk,” Gale said.
“This graphical view from a risk scenario allows us to follow the sequence of events from cause to consequences much more linearly without a table full of codes and colors and various other pieces of information,” he said.
Gale showed an example of one scenario using a CyberPHA and a bow tie analysis.
In the CyberPHA, they were able to show a consequence that has a number of causes. There was also some risk scoring along with mitigated risk and a target risk. He then showed some barriers, or countermeasures and recommended countermeasures. But, Gale said, you need to know how to follow through the process. “And that is sometimes a challenge for leadership,” he said.
Whereas the bow tie depiction of the same scenario is much easier to follow from cause a consequence and also allows the ability to do before and after snapshots, Gale said.
More Visual
In the bow tie example of the same scenario he was able to visualize the current risk without any barriers and place, Gale said. Then he was able to show the target state and make recommendations for barriers and see how they interact with the scenario. Then they were able to make an image of the target risk with barriers in place and the risk is now low.
“Bow ties can help provide an intuitive graphical representation of complex risk assessment tables. It can particularly make it much easier for a lay person to look at a bow tie and understand the relationship between cause and effect, then they can by looking at tables,” Cusimano said. “There is a minimal effort to generate bow ties from existing PHA results, particularly when you focus on the high-risk scenarios. The nice thing is you can also have both the before and after view of scenario so how it is currently and what it could be if we add additional barriers.”


This sounds like a carbon copy of what David Hatch (PSI) proposed at HAZ29 It was a good idea then and I think it is still a good idea
Thank you for covering this, Greg. You did a great job summarizing the presentation.