By Gregory Hale
JBS, the largest beef supplier in the world, paid $11 million to attackers that applied ransomware to the company’s network, company officials said Wednesday.
While that may have been the only option the company had to overcome a devastating cyberattack, but on the heels of Colonial Pipeline paying $4.4 million (which the government has subsequently recovered $2.3 million), attacks may soon be on the rise. That means manufacturers large and small have to become even more vigilant, not only about ransomware, but also about a total security program.
JBS suffered from the attack in May by REvil, one of a number of Russian-speaking hacker gangs, leading meat plants across the U.S. and Australia to shut down for at least a day.
REvil has made millions by hacking organizations, encrypting their files and demanding fees, often large bitcoin payments, in exchange for a decryptor program and a promise not to leak the files to the public.
Payout Decision
“Companies that fall victim to a ransomware attack that affects business operations are faced with a difficult decision,” said Mark Carrigan, senior vice president at Hexagon PPM. “The cost to pay the ransom is normally far less than the impact associated with lost operations. Additionally, without paying the ransom, companies are not sure how long it will take to restore operations, further pressuring them to pay. While there is a risk that the perpetrators will not provide the decryption keys after the ransom is paid, that risk is low. The attacker’s business model would suffer if word spreads that payment will not allow a company to restore operations – providing the decryption key is just good business.”
Carrigan added hackers will keep attacking as long as companies continue with minimal security programs and procedures.
“While news that the FBI was able to recover a large portion of the ransom paid by Colonial is positive, until we can effectively interrupt the lucrative ransomware business, these attacks will continue,” Carrigan said. “The reward is just too great for these bad actors to ignore. It will take a combination of effective prosecution by the U.S. government and defensive strategies implemented by industry to stop this flood of attacks. Companies need to focus on strategies to improve business resiliency to effectively recover from an attack without needing to obtain decryption keys. It can be done, but requires focus, technology and investment.”
In a statement, JBS said while it was able to get most of its systems running without REvil’s help, it chose to pay to keep its files safe.
“At the time of payment, the vast majority of the company’s facilities were operational,” the company said in an emailed statement, adding it “made the decision to mitigate any unforeseen issues related to the attack and ensure no data was exfiltrated.”
Charles Carmakal, the chief technology officer of the cybersecurity firm Mandiant, said in a published report while such a price might seem high, it’s not unusual for a successful ransomware attack.
Payment Amount
“For an organization like theirs, it feels like it’s a pretty common extortion demand,” Carmakal said in the report. “For bigger organizations, you’ll tend to see eight-figure extortion demands. Sometimes, you’ll see what I believe are really large demands, going up to $40, $45, $50 million. Most people don’t want to pay that much and will try to negotiate it down as best they can.”
Security professionals and the U.S. government has long recommended ransomware victims not pay their attackers, even though most ransomware gangs aren’t sanctioned entities and paying them isn’t illegal.
JBS Chief Executive Andre Nogueira defended the decision to pay.
“This was a very difficult decision to make for our company and for me personally,” Nogueira said in the statement. “However, we felt this decision had to be made to prevent any potential risk for our customers.”
Best Practices
For the manufacturing industry or any organization that leverages an industrial control system, the following are some best practices to protect against ransomware:
- Have a resilient model for operations (performing and testing backups, offline backups, testing operational restoration)
- Network segmentation – user operate in an industry where end-of-life legacy operating systems still support some of the most critical manufacturing processes. Segmenting these devices from the rest of the network can drastically reduce the cyber risk of that system. Through network access control lists (ACL), bump-in-the-wire firewall solutions, host-based firewalls are simple, cost-effective tools that can help stop ransomware from propagating across the network.
- Restricting removable disk – disabling USB drives on computers that connect or are part of the OT device. Help reduce malware infections from dirty USB sticks.
- Enabling least privilege mode on the operating system to restrict execution and access to certain applications.
- Take a holistic security approach that continually identifies, assesses and minimize risks and threats to people, assets and operations, across the lifecycle. That strategy, as well as any technology solutions used to help detect, prevent and mitigate risks, need to end up customized for their unique environments, as well as be flexible enough to change and adapt as their operations and business change.
- Employ defense in depth controls across operations, as well as tested, multi-tiered backups. Routine maintenance, updating and patching also need to be priorities: When they learn about vulnerabilities that impact the devices and systems within their operations, they need to take immediate steps to upgrade to remediated versions or to put into place necessary mitigations that alleviate the threat of exploit.
- Training is critical: Making cybersecurity part of the operations lifecycle requires everyone, everywhere, to be responsible for cybersecurity.
- Application whitelisting or application safelisting, which is highly effective, which protects against unknown viruses.
- Good back-up and restoration program. If your defenses fail, you can at least recover quickly because you have back-ups.
- Have a good inventory of all software, so if you are hit with ransomware you know what you have and you know what you have to restore.
- Patching is also another measure to protect. It is never easy to implement a patch management program, but quite a few companies have come to the realization they need to patch.

