By Gregory Hale
Ransomware. Just the suggestion of that one word can send a cold shiver down the spine of any manufacturing executive or security professional. Why of all industries is ransomware hitting the manufacturing sector at such a prodigious rate? Why now? What can be done to fend off an attack that can devastate any company?
The very simple answer is ransomware is a profit center for any motivated attacker. But there is much more involved that just that.
“This has been going on for a while. But there is no doubt it is on the rise. Cyber criminals have realized it is a good market for them,” said John Cusimano, vice president of industrial cybersecurity at aeSolutions. “Manufacturing and healthcare have been a good target for them. They have recognized for these industries, uptime is so important for them. In some cases, victims are willing to pay the ransom.”
“Ransomware attacks are in the headlines nearly every day. Cybercriminals are after lucrative targets – those whose business continuity is mission and safety-critical where downtime is not an option,” said Marty Edwards, vice president of operational technology security at Tenable. “For this reason, we’re seeing more attacks against sectors like healthcare and critical infrastructure.”
Make no mistake, however, ransomware is financially motivated.
Deep Pockets
“The reason why ransomware criminals are heavily targeting manufacturing companies and critical infrastructure organizations is the fact they have deeper pockets,” said Dewan Chowdhury, chief executive and founder of security provider, malcrawler. “The likelihood of a person paying for a ransom to decrypt their data is minimal. On the other hand, the likelihood of manufacturing companies or hospitals is much higher because the data is needed for operational needs.”
Eric Byres, chief executive at aDolus agrees about the motivating factors.
“When asked why he robbed banks, criminal Willie Sutton simply replied, ‘Because that’s where the money is.’ To summarize, a running modern ransomware campaign is extremely lucrative and almost risk-free,” Byres said. “If you are running cyber-criminal operation, why do anything else?
“From what I can tell ransomware is hitting any sector that might have money, is poorly secured and has customers, subscribers or citizens that won’t tolerate outages. Dragos reported the number of publicly recorded ransomware attacks against manufacturing has tripled in the last year, but I’d be surprised if ransomware attacks didn’t triple across all sectors. Like municipalities, companies in the manufacturing sector (versus say the energy and O&G sector) tend to have weaker security programs and thus fall victim more often. I don’t think most attackers care about the sector, they just go where the pickings are easiest and payouts are biggest. Specific sectors are ‘self-selecting’ by being the easier targets.”
Constant Threat
“Industrial manufacturing is under threat all the time, and as we have seen in the last few months, increasingly so,” said Jay Abdallah, vice president cybersecurity services at Schneider Electric. “There are several reasons for this: Legacy control technology is notoriously weak and sometimes complex to protect; there has been a substantial increase in remote connectivity, mostly as a result of the Coronavirus; and there is an increasing move toward digital, where companies bring their IT and OT systems closer together, sometimes resulting in cybersecurity gaps that give attackers access. We could mention others, but the increase in ransomware attacks, beginning primarily with the emergence of the SNAKE virus earlier this year, is a manifestation of these trends.”
“Threat actors are targeting manufacturers because they know that a) they’re susceptible since they’re running legacy gear; and, b) it’s time critical,” said Bradford Hegrat, principal director at Accenture Security. “Manufacturers often have a critical timeline for their supply chains; whereas, enterprises typically have more flexibility regarding the timing of the operations of their systems. That added timing pressure is sometimes enough…”
“Often manufacturing automation and warehouse systems are long-term investments, often operating with older devices, and older servers/workstations,” said Graham Speake, senior security manager at Accenture Security. “Often, Microsoft Windows is used at the higher levels of the process, often with out-of-date operating systems and/or missing patches and little to no anti-virus software. These systems are often seen by the system owner as low risk due to their function and their perceived interest to hackers. These systems are usually coupled to business systems, which have evolved from simple systems and interfaces to newer systems such as SAP. Often multiple systems are operated in conjunction with each other, with multiple firewall rules routing traffic between business network and control network. All of this has allowed access points for ransomware to take hold in either the business or control network.”
Cusimano said some of his customers have been victims of ransomware attacks. “I don’t know any that paid the ransom. They all restored on their own. In some cases, it was weeks of effort to get back to normal. It depends on how much it spread. Some suffered downtime and some were able to keep running in a limited capacity.”
After the fact, though, good companies will do a post-mortem and lessons learned approach, Cusimano said. “We have done post incident analysis where a lot of companies want to know that we have gotten through this, but how can we not have this happen again.”
Research on Rise
Lessons learned also goes the other way as Chowdhury is seeing attackers’ level of research is on the rise.
“The criminals behind many famous and successful ransomware attacks are putting an impressive effort in their due diligence to find companies with operational technology and find out what type of vendors are being used at that manufacturing facility,” he said. “Armed with that type of data, they send a malicious email with malware to targeted companies disguising to be vendors for their robots, or large system integrators, or a PLC/RTU manufacturer. They are targeting vertical industries, just like how a successful marketing company promotes the product to the same industry.”
Reasons for attacks have changed over the years and ransomware is now top of the heap.
“My main focus was dealing with nation-states attempting to steal or sabotage operational technology equipment in industries,” Chowdhury said. “In the past three years, the majority of the focus has been dealing with ransomware. We’ve witnessed failure from cybersecurity companies who were focused on dealing with cyber-attacks and malware that were intended to steal intellectual property, but their technology stack failed against ransomware. Hence, we are seeing victims of ransomware being Fortune 100 companies to large public institutes that have cybersecurity products deployed in their environment to protect their infrastructure.”
Are companies generally trying to fight off ransomware or deciding to pay?
“I think it comes down to preparedness,” Edwards said. “If a company has a solid backup and recovery plan and can rebuild, then they go that route. Unfortunately, some companies find themselves unprepared and have to consider paying the ransom. Most ransomware leverages known vulnerabilities, so having a solid cybersecurity program where you are evaluating and mitigating vulnerabilities in your networked assets – both IT and OT in today’s converged environment – is a must. This is along with having a good backup and recovery program in place, with offline non-networked backups that you regularly test and exercise.”
Two Approaches
“There are two different schools of thought,” Cusimano said. “One is you never pay the ransom, and the other is sometimes you do pay the ransom, if you can trust they are actually going to give you the encryption keys. I have heard some stories where they pay the ransom, and they didn’t get their data back.”
“Unfortunately, many companies have been paying the ransom, as they had no resilient model to restore their data from some backup,” Chowdhury said. “You can hire individuals as ransomware negotiator who can facilitate the entire process when dealing with ransoms in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. It’s quite fascinating for companies that utilize OT technology, the real-time systems are critical, but when you look at their backup methodology, it’s almost nonexistent.”
Oftentimes, paying is just easier.
“Lack of business continuity (including backups) often ensures that end users have an unenviable decision of either paying the ransom and hopefully getting the system up and running relatively quickly or having downtime and possible consequences of the outage reaching the media,” Speake said. “While most companies decide not to pay the ransom, there are a number who decide it is the better of two evils. Either way, the additional cost of having to mitigate the vulnerability utilizing either internal or more likely an external resource often is as much or more than the event.”
With ransomware becoming more prevalent, security experts say manufacturers need to lock down some simple best practices to protect themselves.
“Before examining what you should do if you are the victim of a ransomware attack – hint: Don’t pay – companies need to look now at how they can prevent an attack,” Abdallah said. “Companies need to take a proactive, standards-based approach to protecting themselves from cyber threats, not just ransomware or other targeted attacks. This includes making cybersecurity the foundation of not just your digital strategy, but your risk-management strategy as well. Because your risks are dynamic– they change every day– your approach to managing these risks needs to be dynamic too.
Best Practices
For the manufacturing industry or any organization that leverages an industrial control system, the following are some best practices to protect against ransomware:
- Have a resilient model for operations (performing and testing backups, offline backups, testing operational restoration)
- Network segmentation – user operate in an industry where end-of-life legacy operating systems still support some of the most critical manufacturing processes. Segmenting these devices from the rest of the network can drastically reduce the cyber risk of that system. Through network access control lists (ACL), bump-in-the-wire firewall solutions, host-based firewalls are simple, cost-effective tools that can help stop ransomware from propagating across the network.
- Restricting removable disk – disabling USB drives on computers that connect or are part of the OT device. Help reduce malware infections from dirty USB sticks.
- Enabling least privilege mode on the operating system to restrict execution and access to certain applications.
- Take a holistic security approach that continually identifies, assesses and minimize risks and threats to people, assets and operations, across the lifecycle. That strategy, as well as any technology solutions used to help detect, prevent and mitigate risks, need to end up customized for their unique environments, as well as be flexible enough to change and adapt as their operations and business change.
- Employ defense in depth controls across operations, as well as tested, multi-tiered backups. Routine maintenance, updating and patching also need to be priorities: When they learn about vulnerabilities that impact the devices and systems within their operations, they need to take immediate steps to upgrade to remediated versions or to put into place necessary mitigations that alleviate the threat of exploit.
- Training is critical: Making cybersecurity part of the operations lifecycle requires everyone, everywhere, to be responsible for cybersecurity.
- Application whitelisting or application safelisting, which is highly effective, which protects against unknown viruses.
- Good back-up and restoration program. If your defenses fail, you can at least recover quickly because you have back-ups.
- Have a good inventory of all software, so if you are hit with ransomware you know what you have and you know what you have to restore.
- Patching is also another measure to protect. It is never easy to implement a patch management program, but quite a few companies have come to the realization they need to patch.

