By Gregory Hale
Change and the evolution of security products is inevitable, so asset owners should not get caught up in the hype of buying one product thinking it will solve all their security problems, but rather, take a clear thoughtful approach and lay out a solid strategy.
“When we talk about products, we have to be careful. Companies, especially senior management, believe they can solve problems by buying a product. It can help, but it won’t be a solid answer,” said Dale Peterson, founder and chief executive at Digital Bond, last week during a keynote at the PAS Optics 2020 virtual conference. “You really need to come up with a product strategy.”
When talking about products, Peterson said you often hear this product may work in this industry, but it won’t work in the industrial control system (ICS) environment. But, he said, that is not true. Just take a look at things like Ethernet, virtualization, cloud service, and intrusion detection to name a few.
“If you get some knee jerk reaction when someone is talking to you about a product saying this won’t work in ICS, chances are it probably will eventually. It just might be a couple of years later, so keep an open mind.”
Application Whitelisting
Peterson talked about a few areas that show some potential in terms of technology like, application whitelisting replacing antivirus. “It is a much better solution. It is an ideal technology in the ICS space.”
He also talked about endpoint protection.
“I have been waiting for someone to come out with something for endpoint protection for PLCs or controllers,” he said. “I have seen some research papers, but that is bleeding edge, but I believe we are at least three years away from a credible solution.”
In this era when remote access has become more ingrained in everybody’s lives with the work from home movement, Peterson shared an important reminder on an important security component.
“The key thing is you have to have two-factor authentication for remote access,” he said. “The vast majority of incidents you hear about in ICS are related to someone getting on the enterprise network and riding in on credentials they recovered, single-factor credential remote access. You really should be looking at two-factor authentication remote access.”
Data Diode
On the perimeter front, he said one interesting area is unidirectional, or a one-way data diode, which allows you to send information from the control system to the enterprise or from the safety system to the control system.
“We are seeing it used more because people say it is unhackable because you can’t send things back in the other direction,” Peterson said. “We are also seeing this will be less used because more two-way communication is now being required. More communication to the cloud and more communication to the enterprise. But if you are doing something like predictive maintenance, unidirectional is perfect for that.”
But the main thought Peterson wanted to touch on was the detection product market that started out in 2015 with multiple start-ups that had incredible amounts of venture capital funding behind them.
“What started as the detection market in 2015; there were about 30 companies that came out with very similar products to passively listen to the traffic on the network,” he said. “It got more mindshare than it deserved.”
The issue was companies thought these products would be an answer to their security problems, but instead they cost quite a bit of money and they didn’t really detect attacks because there was another problem.
Asset Discovery
The other problem was when these companies came in to conduct a demo, the asset owners realized the products were finding assets on the network they didn’t even know existed. In what has become a cliché these days, but is true: You can protect what you don’t know what you have.
“You want to spend your time and money on that which will maximize your risk reduction,” he said.
As these detection companies started to add asset inventory capabilities, they ended up saying “all you need to do for asset management is buy our products and you get detection and you get asset management. But not really,” Peterson said.
With the products you get partial OK asset inventory, but true asset management includes things like configuration management and change management. “There are a lot of elements to a true asset management solution,” he said.
That thought led Peterson to say, “I am convinced asset management and detection will be two separate solutions just because they have two different purposes and it is hard to build a product that does both of them well. You will want an asset management product that does that well and a detection product that does that well and you will want them to talk to each other.”
When it comes to purchasing detection products, Peterson said to think about it before making a purchase.
Starting Point
“You don’t really want to start with a detection product. I suggest you create a list of sources of detection information and prioritize that list and decide where I am going to get the best information. If you look at your antivirus or whitelisting alerts, if you are not monitoring that, you don’t need one of the detection products because that is something that is high fidelity. Every time you see and alert, you need to investigate.”
Also, if you detect something what do you do next?
“You need to be able think about what is your response going to be,” Peterson said. “If you spend a lot of money and effort detecting potential incidents and don’t have the capability to respond, what have your really accomplished? You need to get your response in place before you invest in detection.”
Instead, Peterson said he would start with an asset management solution.
“You can get immediate value with an asset management solution. Then after you have that in place, get a detection solution.”
Security has come a long way over the past 10 years, where the industry has gone from an “I will get to security later on,” to an avalanche of products out there that can make a manufacturing environment more secure.
The catch is you have to have a strategy.

