By Gregory Hale
When it comes to safety, the argument over the years has always been about whether it should be separate or integrated. Put that thought on pause for a moment as the talk now can center on integrating safety with cybersecurity.

“Widespread digitalization and automation of chemical process and increasing connectivity through the Internet, and that it increases cyber risk, said Ashit Dalal, principal and director of IT/OT cybersecurity and risk advisory at eDelta Consulting during his talk last week on “Integrating Process Safety and Cybersecurity in Chemical Process Industry for Better EHSS Performance” at the virtual Spring 21 + 17th GCPS joint AIChE and CCPS meeting. “Increased number of devices now connected to the Internet and hence increase the attack surface.”

There are reasons for this, Dalal said, including: Inadequate or lack of basic cyber hygiene of chemical plants and operations, use of legacy systems running Windows XP or 7, and unchecked remote access granted to vendors, service providers and employees.

Dalal discussed major cyberattacks that occurred in the industry over the last eight years, including Stuxnet, Shamoon 2, Flame, the sniper attack on PG&E substation in California, the German Steel Mill incident and the attacks in the Ukraine.

Schneider Bold

Triton Attack
He also pointed out another of the major attacks being the Triton incident where a safety system was attacked and taken over along with the distributed control system.

“Fortunately, the attack did not go through,” he said. “If it did go through it could have resulted in a major impact.”

He also mentioned the ransomware attack on Norsk Hydro which did not impact the operations side as much as it did the business side. The end result, though, is the attack resulted in a $40 million loss.

He also mentioned the attack at the water plant in Oldsmar, Florida, where an attacker tried to increase the amount of sodium hydroxide, or lye, by a factor of more than 100, from 100 parts per million to 11,100 parts per million.

So, with the increase in cybersecurity having a potential impact on safety, Dalal gets it. He wants to see how safety and security can come along on the same path.

“One of the things I see in the chemical industry is safety and security are not properly aligned and they are in conflict with each other,” he said. “That can cause a problem and we have seen that in several facilities. If they are not properly aligned or in sync with each other, it can result in immediate issues especially when you are dealing with safety systems, safety instrumented systems, and when you have layers or protection that are not adequately designed.”

Dalal discussed an IBM survey where respondents said 74 percent of companies do not have an OT risk assessment strategy and 78 percent do not have OT security polices, and 81 percent do not have an OT incident response plan.

IT-OT Convergence
That has got to change, especially in this era of IT and OT convergence.

When you talk about the digital environment you have to look at the relationship between IT and OT and the differences, he said. IT’s main focus is on confidentiality and the OT side focuses on availability.

He then talked about the similarities between cybersecurity and safety. When looking at a typical chemical plant, there is the idea of segmenting zones. “When you have multiple chemical processes working in the plant you can put them in a zone and each zone is segmented from the other one. One zone can prevent an attack.”

Within that segmentation, you create a defense on depth architecture. “You need to protect each layer and make each layer independent of each other which can give you enough time to respond and recover in case if there is an attack,” Dalal said.

The same thing can be said about safety, where you create independent layers of protection, which starts with basic controls, process alarms, and operator supervision then to critical alarms, operator supervision and manual intervention, then to automation action with the SIS, then physical protection (relief devices), then physical protection in the form of dikes, and then finally plant emergency response.

“This is something we see in process safety all the time. Where you identify a hazard at the plant level with any chemical process and how you are going to control it through all the safety interlocks and alarms and any automatic actions you need to take. You need to have all the devices and safety valves, and rupture discs. In case one fails, they are independent of each other and it can be contained within the plant and the plant’s boundaries.”

Safety-Security Similarities
With the similarities between the two, Dalal said cybersecurity and safety can be thought of in the same breath.

“It would be a very nice thing to do if you want to have an integrated approach to safety and cybersecurity,” he said.

Dalal then gave his Ten Commandments for an integrated approach for managing cyber, EHS and safety risk:

  1. Keep an updated inventory of assets and devices
  2. Use a framework or standard
  3. Deploy strong access control and authentication practices, embrace least privilege
  4. Extend key OSHA PSM principles of process safety to cybersecurity
  5. Implement robust vendor management program
  6. Implement robust and integrated cyber and safety incident management program
  7. Integrate safety and cybersecurity by integrating cybersecurity considerations into traditional process hazard analysis
  8. Invest in continuous training and education
  9. Implement proper network segmentation between IT and OT environment including zones and conduits approach
  10. Take out cyber insurance to protect the facility

“If implemented correctly, these commandments would go a long way to consistently achieve improved EHSS performance,” he said. “As cyberattacks on the chemical industry continue to rise, we need to pay more attention to secure chemical facilities with a defense in depth approach. An integrated approach along with suitable attention to IT/OT architecture can address both safety and security.”

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This