Your company is hit and taken over by an attacker seeking money in an exchange to return the system back to its rightful owners. A classic ransomware scenario. Law enforcement says not to pay, the theory of business continuity says, not so fast, we should pay to get our systems back up and running.

Therein lies the rub, what should a company do if it is hit by a ransomware attack?

If you are Colonial Pipeline and meat supplier, JBS, you pay – and pay handsomely. But if you are with the FBI, then you say, no.

In seeking an answer to that question, a pair of College of Business professors and their doctoral student at The University of Texas at Arlington (UTA) looked into how ransomware attacks sometimes pit organizations against the law enforcement agencies trying to protect them.

Kay-Yut Chen, Jingguo Wang and Yan Lang are authors of a new study entitled, “Coping with Digital Extortion: An Experimental Study on Benefit Appeals and Normative Appeals.” Chen and Wang are professors of information systems and operations management at UTA. Lang is a doctoral student in the department.

Schneider Bold

In its study, the researchers said companies are finding it makes sense to negotiate with their attackers to drive down the cost of the ransom. But such behavior in turn incentivizes attackers to continue and runs counter to FBI guidance.

“From a policy perspective, the FBI is telling businesses not to give in,” Wang said. “But we’ve found that when you’re trying to run a business, there is almost always a ransom that becomes similar to a break-even point.”

This study investigated in part how to nudge companies toward adopting strategies that decrease the risk of digital extortion.

Along those lines, the researchers used behavioral game theory to study tactics such as investing in cybersecurity or refusing to pay ransoms and used human subject experiments to analyze strategic decisions made by interacting players.

“We reason that when companies are hit with ransomware attacks, even if they pay the ransom, they still must pay for added security,” Chen said.

National data shows these ransomware attacks are spiking, with experts saying an organization is attacked by ransomware every 40 seconds. Earlier this year, Colonial Pipeline, one of the nation’s largest pipelines carrying gasoline and jet fuel from Texas to the East Coast, shut down after a ransomware attack.

“We must convince companies that just because the bad actors come down on the ransom, it doesn’t make it right to pay them – and you’ll probably continue to have problems,” Wang said. “We need to encourage firms to do the right thing in security investing. Recognizing the long-term benefits of this approach could help other companies come to the right decision.”

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This