Rain, and not being able to properly handle it, was the major culprit behind a series of flares and a fire at the Chevron Richmond Refinery in October last year, according to a report.

On October 24, a storm dropped 4 to 6 inches of rain in a 24 hour period at the refinery. Despite the refinery’s efforts to inspect and prepare equipment in preparation of the storm, water breached the building containing electrical switchgear located at the Refinery’s cogeneration plant (cogen), according to the report sent to Matt Kaufman, hazardous materials program director at the Contra Costa Health Services Department.

The water intrusion resulted in an electrical ground fault at 8:09 that activated the safety protection system for the electrical bus, according to the report. This resulted in a full shutdown of one of the two cogen trains, the loss of power to half of the motor control center near the cogen, and the loss of primary power to the cogen control room. Back-up battery power to the control room, called the Uninterrupted Power Supply (UPS), immediately activated to keep the control room in operation. Approximately seven minutes after the UPS was activated, operators lost control board indication for both cogen trains due to a failure of the UPS system. This resulted in the need to shut down the second cogen train in a controlled manner around 8:16.

Without both cogen trains, the refinery was required to go into steam load shed forcing multiple process units to shut down, according to the report. The incident resulted in visible flaring from the fluidized catcracker, alkylation, low sulfur fuel oil, north isomax, south isomax, and Richmond lube oil project flares. Efforts to stabilize, troubleshoot, and recover were initiated.

Separately, when the first cogen train tripped offline, operators in the diesel hydrotreater (DHT) were working to stabilize the unit due to loss of steam, but once the second cogen train tripped offline, the rapid loss of steam resulted in safety systems activating in the DHT and the unit shutting down at approximately 8:35, according to the report. These abnormal conditions created a large temperature differential between the two sides of a heat exchanger resulting in failure of the sealing surface, or joint, on the heat exchanger. This resulted in a small hydrocarbon leak that caught fire at the DHT at approximately 08:55. This fire was observed and extinguished within 10 minutes of initial notification to Chevron Fire Department using in plant firefighting equipment.

Schneider Bold

The following items have been identified as key root causes and include measures to prevent recurrence for the:

Loss of cogens:
Root cause: The roof on the building housing critical electrical components for the cogen was not able to handle the severe weather that occurred.

  • Preventative measure: Repair roof of building, which is now complete
  • Preventative measure: Assess potential design changes for roof in order to withstand severe weather events and assess current roof inspection processes, which is due by December 15 this year

Root cause: The cogen UPS system did not function as designed to provide backup power.

  • Preventative measure: Assess cogen UPS design by working with the UPS manufacturer and implement actions to improve functionality of cogen backup power system, which is due by Decmeber 15 this year.

DHT exchanger fire:
Root cause: The heat exchanger sealing surface, or joint, was not adequately designed for the transient conditions experienced.

  • Preventative measure: Implement new joint design and new heat exchanger gasket assembly instructions for the exchanger, which has been completed

Click here for more on the report.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This