By Gregory Hale
While it often goes under appreciated, safety systems and devices need constant care and vigilance to ensure a facility and workers stay safe and operating in a proper fashion in an effort to keep pushing product out the door.

In addition, with the advent of cybersecurity and new technologies, safety is becoming a much more dynamic environment than it has been in years past.

Along those lines, Emerson Exchange Virtual Series focused this month on process safety issues and how up to date technology can help keep facilities and workers much safer. In one session during the series, the topic of discussion was overfill prevention and proof-testing for tank gauging.

In the shadow of the anniversary of the Buncefield, UK, incident in December 2005 and the CAPECO, incident in Puerto Rico in 2009, being able to ensure the massive fuel tanks do not end up overfilled become paramount.

Schneider Bold

Overfill Disasters
The December 2005 Buncefield disaster occurred when a fuel storage tank overfilled and caused a massive explosion. A high-level switch should have detected the tank was full and shut off the supply, but it failed to operate. That switch failure should have triggered an alarm, but that also failed. As a result, 300 metric tons of unleaded fuel spilled through the roof vents, down the side of the tank, onto the ground inside the semi-enclosed compound surrounding several tanks. By 6:01 a.m., the first explosion occurred.

In the Caribbean Petroleum (CAPECO) terminal facility incident, was jarringly similar to the Buncefield. The 2009 incident occurred when gasoline overflowed and sprayed out from a large above ground storage tank, forming a 107-acre vapor cloud which then ignited.

“After a UK investigation, among other things, they said use proper safety certified equipment according to IEC 61511, if they had done at Buncefield this incident never would have happened,” said Johan Sandberg, business development manager at Emerson.

CSB report in the CAPECO case, Sandberg said, found systems were inoperable and they did not have a high alarm device to as a further form of protection.

In this case following standards like API 2350 and IEC 61511 could help save the day.

Continuous Gauging
One level of tank gauging is by using a point-level as a high-level alarm, which is a popular device used today, easy to understand and is low cost. However, they provide information, it does not offer diagnostics, provides little information from the tank and has a fixed alarm level. A continuous gauging as a high-level alarm provides online gauging, quick proof testing can occur from the control room, it has an easy to change alarm level, has remote diagnostics and provides tank information 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

In short, being able to test the equipment on a regular basis, can help overcome an overfill situation.

There have been overfill accidents caused by inadequate and faulty equipment.

“As a result of these incidents, more pressure has resulted in overfill pressure requirements on tanks with fuel or other tanks with things like chemicals. Tank gauging is the first layer of defense and then you need a safety layer on top of that. API 2350 and IEC 61511 (standards) state the requirements for overfill safety. In addition, all safety equipment must be tested regularly. This can be done easily with a guided semi-automatic proof testing which makes it easy to perform.”

In facilities where technologies can often be decades old and the mantra of “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” prevails, outdated devices and practices can become obstacles that operational efficiency and can be a safety hazard.

Solving Pressure, Temperature Issues
In another virtual session entitled “Solve 6 Leading Pressure and Temperature Measurement Issues Using Advanced Instrumentation,” Nathan Stokes, director of product management at Rosemount pressure products and Michael Olivier, director of product management at Rosemount temperature products, they talk about the issues that often lead to process upsets or safety risks.

The six issues are:
1. Measurement degradation due to deteriorating instrument wiring
2. Heat tracing headaches.
3. Impulse lines and process connection issues
4. Mechanical Bourdon tube pressure gauge challenges
5. Reducing thermowell safety risks
6. Temperature sensor degradation

In the first issue, measurement degradation due to deteriorating instrument wiring Emerson has a new device can learn the characteristics of the electrical loop and it will monitor the characteristic over time and will notify the operator if there are any changes. The same can be said for the remaining five issues facing operators.

“Everything we talked about can be implemented by making small independent upgrades. Nothing required huge grand effort or capital investment,” Olivier said.

Toxic Gas Detectors
In another session, entitled “Open Path Toxic Gas Detectors: Key to an Integrated Strategy for Worker Safety,” Forrest Francis, global product manager for flame and gas at Emerson talked about detecting for the potential of hydrogen sulfide (H2S), which could lead to a fatal incident.

H2S is a highly toxic compound, normally in gaseous form, that is and capable of incapacitating and fatally injuring workers at low levels of exposure.

One of the most effective detection methods for H2S is using open path gas detectors (OPGD), which use a variety of technologies to “see” the gas with their ability to monitor the absorption of gas by specific wavelengths of light. Emerson implemented ultraviolet (UV) flash technology into their Rosemount 936 OPGD, which provides a solution to keep end users safe.

“It is important for your firm to have proper procedures and equipment and PPE in place to protect everyone form this common and dangerous gas,” Francis said.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This