EDITOR’S NOTE: This is part two in a series of stories on the high-profile incidents hitting the manufacturing automation sector and what some industry experts have to say. This week, we look at possible points of entry, business continuity, and what can those in the industry do to prevent incidents.
By Gregory Hale
Security professionals will talk all day about needing to defend against this and protect against that, and yes, that is an important battle, but in the end they have to build in resiliency to keep the operation running in the event of an incident.
“One thing we have found that people never do and talk about is continuity of business,” said Joel Langill, founder and managing member of the Industrial Control System Cyber Security Institute LLC. “There needs to be a plan in place that allows you to ensure continuity of services in times of adverse events.”
In light of the ransomware attacks that forced Colonial Pipeline and JBS to shut down operations and pay multimillion dollar ransoms, it appears as though they didn’t have some sort of business continuity plan that would provide resilience to keep the company operating.
“Business continuity is not all about security, they create scenarios on what situation you could be in and then put everything into timeframes like what do you do in the first eight hours, then 12 hours, and 24 hours and so on,” Langill said. “All people are doing now is going back to the same set of procedure controls, but no one is looking at seeing the controls are deficient in their own right.
“The whole idea is to shift from somebody looking at 1’s and 0’s on the network to looking at the business and what the business is trying to do. It is about keeping the business running. It is not about 1’s and 0’s. It is not about information, it is about service continuity,” Langill said.
Keep On Operating
He added every company should be able to ensure they have a way to operate a system in some degraded form. “You shouldn’t have to have 100 percent availability of all your assets in order to run. That is where continuity planning works. You start to look at what you need to keep things running,” he said.
One other way for manufacturers to ensure a more secure environment is to outsource its cybersecurity to allow for managed services.
“I think managed services is a good model,” Langill said. “I have gotten calls in the past few weeks, and I am finding people are panicking and now want to establish managed services. Managed detection and response and incident response.”
‘Great Advantage’
“Having a set of eyes to look at the organization’s cybersecurity events and investigate cyber events is always a great advantage,” said Dewan Chowdhury, chief executive and founder of security provider, malcrawler. “Still, an organization should do their due diligence to determine what the outsourced managed service can do to protect them.
“In the past few years, I’ve seen companies go in both directions of outsourcing their cybersecurity monitoring service. They outsource it and a few years later bringing it back in-house as they learned the experiment did not work,” Chowdhury said. “The most common approach I see is a hybrid approach where the organization maintains an internal 9 to 5 incident response staff. After hours utilizes a managed service company to monitor the environment to make it a 24 x 7 operation.”
In this era of increased connectivity, the attack surfaces have grown immensely.
“The most common way ransomware enters a system is through email phishing,” Chowdhury said. “It’s critical to make the end-users fully have good cybersecurity awareness training, so they are the front line of defense to protect an organization’s infrastructure from ransomware. Having proper security awareness training makes the end-users less likely to open up an attachment from an external email address and for them to forward suspicious emails to the appropriate IT team is critical. We are also seeing a complete breakdown and failure of email security solutions that allow these infected emails to bypass the security controls and make it all the way to the end-users mailbox.”
Training a Key
Training and education for staffers are a couple of ways to protect an organization from someone clicking on a malware-riddled attachment.
“The best protection against ransomware is to have an educated end-user community,” Chowdhury said. “The investment into security awareness and training for your end-user can dramatically reduce the risk within an organization for any malware. Complementing an educated end-user community is having good cybersecurity tools to help combat malware. One of the first things to be implemented is to have an email security solution that can remove malware-infected email from coming into a user’s inbox. The other good security tools to have an endpoint agent that has the ability to prevent, and not just detect malware.”
Growth in Business
In the wake of the attacks, there has been a boost in inquires, not to mention business.
“Company executives are becoming aware their software supply chain is vulnerable to multiple threats, including ransomware and they want to manage that risk efficiently and effectively as possible,” said Eric Byres, chief executive at aDolus, a software bill of materials (SBoMs) provider for the ICS/OT sector.
There has been an increase in companies interested in products and services to protect their infrastructure from ransomware attacks, Chowdhury said.
“I think the industry has seen many CIOs and CISO’s that are sweating and worried about being a statistic in the game of ransomware,” he said. “And unfortunately, they are making ad hoc decisions that are not strategic.”
Making smart decisions means the future for cybersecurity in the era of digitization is the industry cannot focus purely on OT, rather it needs to be a part of an overall program for the entire company.
“The most important thing is to have a comprehensive security program not something that is done to meet some requirement, but something that is done as a way of life,” Langill said. “It is all about holistic security.”
Holistic Security
“Stovepipe security is a lost cause,” Byres said. “Today we need all systems to work together so we need a holistic security program. As Joe Blount, the chief executive of Colonial Pipeline testified to Congress, they shut their pipeline down, not because it got infected, but to protect it. I also suspect they also shut down because you can’t run a pipeline today without the supporting billing and metering infrastructure. There is no point moving oil when you’ve lost track of who’s oil it is. Like it or not, today’s processes work efficiently because of the company wide integration between all parts of the company including OT, IT, accounting, inventory, HVAC etc. We can’t go back so now we need to create better holistic security programs to secure the entire company.”
With attacks that have happened and for ones that may come in the future, it is simple to fall into a funk, but all is not bleak. Instead, security professionals just need to remain positive and know they will come out ahead.
“It is really sad we are planning for the worst, rather than trying to prevent the worst from happening,” Langill said.

