By Gregory Hale
From consumers needing to quench their thirst to a nuclear plant needing it to help create steam to generate electricity, water is a vital and often underappreciated – and under protected – resource for the entire world population.
That is why hacks on water facilities like the one in Oldsmar, Florida, and a San Francisco Bay Area water treatment facility this year and one in Kansas a few years back point out that understaffed and low technology facilities can often be a sitting duck when it comes to an attack.
On top of that, as the West Coast braces for water shortages due to decreased rainfall and snowfall and a record-setting heat wave, securing these resources is becoming paramount as these systems are becoming increasingly lucrative for attackers. Questions do remain as to how these underfunded water facilities can protect themselves.
“I believe they have to make the investments in improving the cybersecurity of those facilities,” said Marty Edwards, vice president of OT Security at Tenable. “It is no longer a discretionary expense, it is something that is absolutely necessary to do when you are talking about the safety and security of the water supply for a city. That is no different than if you should have a chain link fence and physical security measures in place so people can’t walk up to the water clarifier. You have to make those investments.”
Investment in Protection
Those investments could have worked for the known facilities that suffered an attack.
In the Oldsmar water plant attack, someone remotely accessed a computer for the city’s water treatment system and briefly increased the amount of sodium hydroxide, or lye, by a factor of more than 100, from 100 parts per million to 11,100 parts per million. Thanks to an operator who witnessed the attack going on, he was able to quickly change the setting back to 100 parts per million.
At a San Francisco Bay Area water treatment facility in mid-January, an attacker was able to get into the system and delete programs used to treat drinking water. While the attacker did not try to poison the water, the idea someone got in can keep any security professional up at night.
Meanwhile, a Kansas man is facing charges for accessing a computer system and tampering with a rural Kansas public water system. Wyatt A. Travnichek, 22, of Ellsworth County, Kansas ended up charged in April with one count of tampering with a public water system and one count of reckless damage to a protected computer during unauthorized access.
The indictment said on March 27, 2019, Travnichek accessed the Ellsworth County Rural Water District’s protected computer system without authorization. During this unauthorized access, Travnichek is charged with shutting down the processes at the facility which affect the facilities cleaning and disinfecting procedures with the intention of harming the Ellsworth Rural Water District No. 1, also known as Post Rock Rural Water District.
Those are three cases where the organizations could have benefited from governmental assistance, so the facility could invest in proper technology and train workers.
Government Trying to Help
“Hopefully, we will see some of the infrastructure funding being discussed on The Hill trickle down into these types of areas,” Edwards said. “We are advocating loudly the administration needs to consider cybersecurity as part of these infrastructure bills. We need to build it in from the beginning and not bolt it on later on.”
To that end, the Biden administration is supporting a bill that would appropriate grants to boost cybersecurity of water treatment facilities.
One bill, S. 914 promotes resiliency projects to address the impacts of climate change and makes explicit that cybersecurity projects are eligible for key programs, according to the Office of Management and Budget.
Also, the U.S. House of Representatives’ Transportation and Infrastructure (T&I) Committee this month marked up and advanced H.R. 1915, the Water Quality Protection and Job Creation Act of 2021. This legislation follows the Senate’s passage in May of its clean water reauthorization package, S. 914, the Senate Drinking Water and Wastewater Infrastructure Act of 2021 (DWWIA).
This is setting the stage for increased funding year over year that better reflects the critical needs for clean water investment.
“A local water authority owned and operated by a county or local government, there should be an influx of resources into these areas,” Edwards said. “The time for talk is over, the time for action is now.”
In most cases, water facilities need the assistance because the technology is there.
Technology is Ready to Go
“There are a number of technological solutions that can help detect when changes are being made without authorization,” Edwards said. “There should be some visibility of where interconnections are on the systems. If there is an unsecure remote access conduit or pathway into the environment, that is something you should know as a chief information security officer. The chief information security officer should be able to make the decision on if the connection is warranted, what is the risk of the connection, how do we protect the connection with multi-factor authentication or something.”
Edwards said protecting water facilities against an attack is no longer a technological problem.
“We have the products and technology,” he said. “We have the people that understand this. For the most part, it is a decision organizations need to make to make the investment.”
While the industry is often slow to react, but with the high-profile attacks hitting the industry, whether it is a supply chain attack like SolarWinds, or a ransomware attack like the Colonial Pipeline or with beef supplier, JBS, more companies are starting to get on board.
The mindset is changing, Edwards said. Boards of directors are waking up and going to the chief executive and saying you need to fix this. What is our risk? We need to make sure we are doing something. Then the CEO goes to the chief information security officer and says we need to fix this, so we have visibility.
‘The People Part’
“We have the right tools here, it is just a matter of deploying them in a smart way,” he said. “If it is no longer a technology issue, you have to have the governance, the policy and the process in place to use the solution. If you put a security solution in place, like in the case of this water incident, and the security solution sends an alert saying we have detected a security issues, if there is no one there to hear that to take action, it is a wasted investment. People, people, people. You definitely have to invest in the people part.”
Oftentimes, attacks make the news and then end up forgotten in the next news cycle. That is where vigilance, perseverance and resiliency come in to play.
“The tempo is increasing,” Edwards said. “The volume is increasing. So, we just need to keep paying attention.”

